Skip to main content

Research Repository

Advanced Search

Contractors' Perspectives on Delays in Healthcare Projects: A Tale of Two Contrasting Provisions

Thurairajah, Niraj; Rathnasinghe, Akila; Roberts, Charlie; McAdam, Brodie; Abwunza, Allan

Contractors' Perspectives on Delays in Healthcare Projects: A Tale of Two Contrasting Provisions Thumbnail


Authors

Niraj Thurairajah

Akila Rathnasinghe

Charlie Roberts

Allan Abwunza



Abstract

Many construction projects are delayed due to a range of factors, including the unique spatial and environmental context of every construction site, the challenges of maintaining quality, and the timing of decision making around design. In consequence, construction contracts include mechanisms to accommodate delay while maintaining enforceability. Different standard forms of contract (SFC) adopt different approaches to managing delay and lack consistency in accommodating delays of the same nature. This study selects two SFCs commonly used in UK construction projects, New Engineering Contract (NEC) and Joint Contracts Tribunal (JCT) suites, and proposes a common approach to managing delays, focusing particularly on the handling of the compensation event (CE) and Relevant Event (RE) mechanisms in those respective contracts. Using a qualitative methodology, a multi-case study analysis was conducted comprising four general contractors utilizing JCT and NEC SFCs. The case studies enabled the analytic comparison of delay-caused challenges as between different projects delivered using different SFCs. The findings reveal that while on JCT-based projects general contractors have typically suffered cash flow and programming issues caused by employer failures to adhere to contractual timescales for assessing requests for extensions of time, on NEC-based projects general contractors have suffered CE-related issues associated with programming and administration. Further findings were that the common challenges of both CE and RE management processes were high volume, assessment and timescales of claims, as well as timing and collaboration. Developing from these findings, recommendations are made for additional clauses to be added to SFCs to achieve a consistent approach towards construction delays.

Citation

Thurairajah, N., Rathnasinghe, A., Roberts, C., McAdam, B., & Abwunza, A. (in press). Contractors' Perspectives on Delays in Healthcare Projects: A Tale of Two Contrasting Provisions. Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction, 17(1), https://doi.org/10.1061/jladah.ladr-1145

Journal Article Type Article
Acceptance Date Jul 8, 2024
Online Publication Date Oct 7, 2024
Deposit Date Aug 16, 2024
Publicly Available Date Oct 7, 2024
Print ISSN 1943-4162
Electronic ISSN 1943-4170
Publisher Coasts, Oceans, Ports and Rivers Institute
Peer Reviewed Peer Reviewed
Volume 17
Issue 1
DOI https://doi.org/10.1061/jladah.ladr-1145

Files





You might also like



Downloadable Citations