Skip to main content

Research Repository

Advanced Search

Revisiting Critical Systems Thinking: Enhancing the Gaps Through Sustainability and Action Methodologies

Albakri, Mohammed; Wood‐Harper, Trevor

Revisiting Critical Systems Thinking: Enhancing the Gaps Through Sustainability and Action Methodologies Thumbnail


Authors

Trevor Wood‐Harper



Abstract

Critical systems thinking (CST) is a holistic framework that has proven instrumental in understanding and addressing complex problems across various domains, including social, environmental, and economic systems. Despite its longstanding reputation for fostering a comprehensive approach, its limitations in effectively addressing contemporary sustainability issues necessitate a critical reassessment. This paper aims to explore the CST paradox, reconciling the need for critical engagement with practical constraints, while proposing a novel framework designed to enhance the efficacy of CST in practice. Insights from prominent systems thinkers, such as Jackson, Checkland Flood, and Midgley, are drawn upon to trace the evolution of CST, employing a critical analysis of existing frameworks and methodologies. Sustainability, which encompasses environmental, economic and social dimensions, serves as an appropriate backdrop for the application of CST, reflecting a complex‐pluralist ethos. Furthermore, the importance of addressing power dynamics, inequalities, and the ethical‐political dimensions inherent in sustainability challenges aligns with the complex‐coercive nature of CST. This paper advocates for the incorporation of action research, participatory action research and action learning (AR/PAR/AL) into CST, resulting in a more comprehensive toolkit for confronting today's pressing sustainability imperatives. Ultimately, the proposed framework seeks to strengthen the relevance and effectiveness of CST in tackling contemporary societal challenges.

Journal Article Type Article
Acceptance Date Nov 2, 2024
Online Publication Date Nov 21, 2024
Deposit Date Dec 6, 2024
Publicly Available Date Dec 6, 2024
Journal Systems Research and Behavioral Science
Print ISSN 1092-7026
Electronic ISSN 1099-1743
Publisher Wiley
Peer Reviewed Peer Reviewed
DOI https://doi.org/10.1002/sres.3107
Keywords critical systems practice, critical systems theory, participatory action research, sustainability, action research, action learning, critical systems thinking

Files





You might also like



Downloadable Citations